Sports Illustrated recently unveiled its top 50 most iconic NFL games since 1966, as chosen by a 37-member Blue Ribbon panel. The New York Giants not only made an appearance twice in the top half of the list, but both games chosen made it to the top ten–and with good reason.

Ask any Giants fan, and they’ll tell you—this team feels further from a Super Bowl than ever. The struggles of the past few years bring back haunting memories of the franchise’s “wilderness years” in the 1970s.