When Aubrey Plaza was first announced as a dark witch in Agatha All Along, I thought, “That makes sense.” It was the same feeling for the actress who has dabbled in the dark arts, telling WSJ Magazine, “What’s better than playing in the witch-witchy worlds of witches?”

Aubrey Plaza made her MCU debut in Agatha All Along as Green Witch Rio Vidal, but her connection to Agatha Harkness and history remains a mystery.

WandaVision‘s nosy neighbor turned out to be far more dangerous than most sitcom characters. Now the show’s spinoff starring Kathryn Hahn has introduced its own mysterious witch.